fol. 35r - 36r

Item details

Collection	Daiber I
Ms_no	32
MS Description	84 folios; 21×15 cm; 15-27 lines; naskhi (different hands). Modern half-leather binding. Copied in 1260/1844 by Muhammad Ibn Muhammad al-Hassi (?) al-Wahi (?) (28v; 35r) in 1182/1768-9 (84r) and in 1160/1747 (49r).
Item_no	1137
Item Description	The author may be al-Sayyid al-Sharif al-Jurjani السيد الشريف الجرجاني (died 816/1413 see GAL II 216; S II 305) who is called al-Muhaqqiq al-Sharif in the Berlin ms. 1790. The text is not mentioned anywhere. It is different from the following treatises Kitab al-Masa'il al-khilafiya bayna al-Maturidiya wa-al-Ash'ariya كتاب المسائل الخلافية بين الماتريدية والأشعرية , ms. Vienna 2111 (Mixt.1112), fol. 1v-81r; Muhammad al-Isbari Qadizade محمد الإسبري قاضي زاده (wrote around 990/1582), Mumayyizat madhhab al-Maturidiya an al-madhahib al-ghayriya مميزة مذهب الماتريدية عن المذاهب الغيرية , ms. Berlin 2492 (mentioned in GAL S II 346 below); Yahya Ibn Ali Ibn Nasuh Naw'i يحيى بن علي بن نصوح نوعي (died 1007/1598; cf. GAL II 443), Risala fi al-farq bayna madhhab al-Asha'ira wa-al-Maturidiya رسالة في الفرق بين مذهب الأشاعرة والماتريدية , ms. Leiden 1882, fol. 39r-40r and Abd al-Rahim Ibn Ali Shaykhzade al-Hanafi عبد الرحيم بن علي شيخ زاده الحنفي , Nazm al-fara'id fi bayan al-masa'il allati waqa'a fiha al-ikhtilaf bayna al-Maturidiya wa-al-Ash'ariya نظم الفرائد في بيان المسائل التي وقع فيها الاختلاف بين الماتريدية والأشعرية (printed Cairo 1323/1905). However, there are some similarities to the more extensive Kitab al-Rawda al-bahiya كتاب الروضة البهية by Abu Udhba أبو عذبة (lived around 1125/1713) cf. e.g. fol. 35r, -3ff. with Abu Udhba (ed. Haydarabad 1322/1904) p.44, 7ff. Both texts may have used a common source, namely the still unedited commentary (written in 757/1356) by Nur al-Din Muhammad al-Shirazi نور الدين محمد الشيرازي on Taj al-Din al-Subki تاج الدين السبكي , Nuniya النونية (cf. on this GAL S II 346 below). - A second ms. (title Risala fi al-masa'il al-niza'iya bayna al-Maturidi wa-al-Ash'ari رسالة في المسائل النزاعية بين الماتريدي والأشعري ) see Union Catalogue (as p.13) 77.
Folios	fol. 35r - 36r
Genre	In Progress
Title	Risala fi al-masa'il al-mukhtalifa bayna al-Maturidiya wa-al-Ash'ari (sic) رسالة في المسائل المختلفة بين الماتريدية والأشعري
Author	al-Muhaqqiq al-Sharif المحقق الشريف

Image link

Citation

al-Muhaqqiq al-Sharif , Risala fi al-masa'il al-mukhtalifa bayna al-Maturidiya wa-al-Ash'ari (sic) , MS Institute for Advanced Studies on Asia, The University of Tokyo, Daiber I-32, fol. 35r - 36r.

Contents of this manuscript

Downloads

IIIF Manifest Metadata (JSON)

Use and citation · CC BY 4.0

Institute for Advanced Studies on Asia, The University of Tokyo